Difference Between 17 HMR and 17 Hornet

The names are befuddling starting from the initial three letters and numbers are indistinguishable, however that is where the likenesses end. The .17 HMR and the .17 Hornet are tremendously various types regarding velocity, energy, and maybe above all, cost and accessibility.

The .17 HMR

A generally fresh debut to the shooting scene, the .17 HMR was presented by Hornady in 2002. The Hornady engineers necked down a .22 magnum cartridge.

The cartridge was intended to beat the norm .22 long rifle in exactness, wind float, and direction, meaning projectile drop over distance. The .17 HMR was likewise a lot calmer than its .22 long rifle heritage.

To sweeten the deal even further, the .17 HMR has seldom experienced the ammo deficiencies found with the .22 long rifle. As supplies of .22 long rifle ammo vanished from racks, numerous varmint trackers and target shooters changed to the .17 HMR.

Youths simply figuring out how to target take shots at the reach, were acquainted with the .17 HMR by grown-ups and the outcomes were phenomenal. The fledgling shooters had incredible accomplishment with the level shooting, simple to deal with lighter cartridge.

The .17 Hornet

The most prominent distinction between the .17 HMR and the .17 Hornet comes in checking out at the foundation of the cartridge. The .17 HMR is a rimfire cartridge, while the .17 Hornet utilizes a groundwork, making it one of the littlest centerfire cartridges at any point imagined.

Centerfire cartridges produce more energy, the rimfire configuration is more affordable to deliver and buy, however the presentation is characteristic of the cost distinction.

The .17 Hornet started life as a “wildcat” cartridge, meaning it was created secretly and reloaded manually. The initial .17 Hornet was made in the mid 1950s by P.O. Ackley. Ackley took .22 Hornet cases and discharge framed the shell down at the neck to situate a .17 type slug. He sold the cartridges secretly to custom weapon proprietors.

The .17 Hornet entered the business market simply 10 years prior. Admired ammo makers Hornady and Remington presented cartridges in 2011.

The two planners started with the current .22 Hornet cartridge and changed it to deal with a .17 type projectile. The outcome was the Remington .17 Fireball and the Hornady .17.

They were quick hits with varmint trackers, and incredibly famous with fur trackers since the minuscule cartridge snuck up all of a sudden, however didn’t harm coyote, fox, and catamount pelts as severely as heavier conventional varmint cartridges like the .223 and .243.

Ballistics: The Crude Information

In the diagram beneath you will promptly see the contrast between the rimfire .17 HMR and the centerfire .17 Hornet.

Regarding gag speed, the .17 Hornet shouts out of the barrel a lot quicker, more than 1000 feet each second quicker at the gag.

The speed differential develops over distance.

The one shared trait between the two cartridges is that the two of them take shots level at 200 yards. The 200-yard range is a standard distance for varmint trackers.

Coyote trackers lean toward the .17 Hornet with its more noteworthy energy. Power, as estimated in energy at the objective, is the primary distinction between these two .17 type cartridges. The .17 Hornet in the well known 15.5-grain shot packs multiple times the energy of its rimfire rival the .17 HMR at 200 yards.

Speed (Feet Each Second)

Cartridge         Muzzle            100 yds           200 yds

.17 Hornet 15.5 Gr.     3860    2924    2159

.17 Hornet 20 Gr.        3650    3077    2574

.17 Hornet 25 Gr.        3375    2842    2368

.17 HMR 15.5 Gr.       2525    1830    1291

.17 HMR 20 Gr.          2375    1775    1274

Energy (Ft. Pounds)

Cartridge         200 yds

.17 Hornet 15.5 Gr.     294

.17 Hornet 20 Gr.        420

.17 Hornet 25 Gr.        448

.17 HMR 15.5 Gr.       57

.17 HMR 20 Gr.          72

Direction (Projectile Drop in Inches)

Cartridge         100 yds           200 yds

.17 Hornet 15.5 Gr.     1.4       0

.17 Hornet 20 Gr.        1.1       0

.17 Hornet 25 Gr.        0.6       0

.17 HMR 15.5 Gr.       1.4       0

.17 HMR 20 Gr.          1.5       0

Great and Awful of .17 HMR and .17 Hornet

Ballistics are one proportion of the value of a cartridge. There are numerous different contemplations too. The .17 HMR can’t contend with regards to crude power, and particularly over distances longer than 200 yards.

Numerous ballistic graphs try not to remember information for the .17 HMR since they become basically a “spent” slug after 250 yards. In any case, inside that 200-yard range, the .17 HRM is an extraordinary stage for sport shooting and varmint hunting, and it comes at a considerably lower cost.

For grassland canines, bunnies, and squirrels, you can’t beat a .17 HMR. The distance in hunting these species and the power in the .17 HMR go with it an extraordinary decision.

The .17 Hornet is a superior cartridge over longer distances, there is no contention. It is likewise better with bigger hunters like wildcats and coyotes. The halting force of the .17 Hornet is great.

That is one reason the early more modest type centerfire cartridges of the 1950s conveyed the names Hornet, Wasp, and Honey bee. They were little however stuffed a major sting when they hit the objective.

The greatest disadvantage to the .17 Hornet is the cost of ammo. In the event that you’re sport shooting at a reach with 100-yard targets, you’ll set aside a ton of cash with the .17 HMR and have some good times shooting. Assuming you’re attempting to go after coyotes or fox at 300 or 400 yards, your main decision is the .17 Hornet.

The .17 Hornet can arrive at those significant distances nevertheless hold the energy to convey a kill shot up to a quarter pretty far.


This is a pleasant cartridge to shoot, in both the .17 HMR and the .17 Hornet setup. The .17 type shot voyages well on the two stages to distances of 200 yards. It’s level shooting, handles the blustery circumstances that varmint trackers frequently experience on the Incomparable Fields and in the Rough Mountains well, and conveys the punch you want.

The disadvantage to the two cartridges is the little drag of the rifle dealing with these small .17 type adjusts. The more modest drag needs nearer consideration subsequent to shooting as not many as 10 rounds.

The more modest region permits buildup to develop rapidly, so customary cleaning of the barrel is important for security, and to guarantee ideal execution.

Your choice on which rifle to buy comes down to cost, and execution. Gauge those variables and you’ll go with the ideal decision.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *